- Oct 30, 2009
- Reaction score
Is it the battle of wounded knee?
With respect, you didn't watch both keepers week in week out. Ikeme was better, it wasn't close. If you take don't take context into account then Ikeme was better than StowellI'll give you a load of Ikeme shockers if you like.
They were both nice people but rubbish,, keepers.
Stearman wasn't amazing, but he wasn't a disaster.Paul Jones was awful. He was generally terrible the first time around as well as the second.
It's like Leon Clarke - we can't say we weren't warned from the first spell, so who knows why on earth we brought them back for a second.
I'm sure someone will correct me, but I can't think of a single player (bar Neil Emblen) who we sold and then brought back in (either permanently or on loan) whose second spell wasn't a disaster. Wayne Clarke's one game doesn't count.