• Welcome, guest!

    This is a forum devoted to discussion of Wolverhampton Wanderers.
    Why not sign up and contribute? Registered members get a fully ad-free experience!

Live Match Discussion: 2020/21

I don't think there is. It is fundamentally flawed in that it just swaps one person's opinion for anothers. But I'll leave it there.
But for clear errors, there is a need.

Lampards 'goal' against Germany in 2010 the obvious example. Whether we would have still lost is irrelevant.

There are penalties been given, and not given, overturned correctly. That can only be a good thing
 
Strange debate.

Saying the technology is the problem is like saying Hawkeye shouldn’t be used definitively for LBW. It isn’t precise, and therefore it isn’t used definitively.

The cameras FPS aren’t accurate so it shouldn’t be used to that level of accuracy.

So poor use of the tech rather than tech being the issue.

Agree with this they’re using tech for the offside which isn’t advance enough to make a call beyond reasonable doubt, it probably only just meets the balance of probability threshold with the defending side always given the benefit of the doubt.
Those ex refs and ex pros saying you can’t be a bit offside no you can’t but you can’t also say categorically that it is offside. Simple way around it is for example freeze the image on Friday night and ask can I see any part of the body that’s clearly offside? Don’t get lines out.
 
Agree with this they’re using tech for the offside which isn’t advance enough to make a call beyond reasonable doubt, it probably only just meets the balance of probability threshold with the defending side always given the benefit of the doubt.
Those ex refs and ex pros saying you can’t be a bit offside no you can’t but you can’t also say categorically that it is offside. Simple way around it is for example freeze the image on Friday night and ask can I see any part of the body that’s clearly offside? Don’t get lines out.
Agree with this, same approach as Rugby is required. It's either a forward pass or it's not but they don't bother getting the lines out (unless it's changed).
 
Goal line technology is a whole other thing, and there is a perfectly good solution for that (as long as it is turned on...)
But for clear errors, there is a need.

Lampards 'goal' against Germany in 2010 the obvious example. Whether we would have still lost is irrelevant.

There are penalties been given, and not given, overturned correctly. That can only be a good thing
It does occasionally correctly overturn a decision, but just as often there are incidents not being reviewed, it is fundamentally flawed.
 
No, it's the technology. There aren't enough fps to give the millimetre precision that drawing the lines assumes.
Make the lines 6 inches thick and call it officials call. If they flag for offside and the armpit is in the 6 inch line then it’s off. If they don’t then it’s a goal
 
The reality is I don’t think we’re a million miles away from the tech being able to tell a ref very quickly whether someone is offside.
The problem is the fact you think you’ve scored, you watch the first replay and still you’ve scored it’s not until the picture is frozen and the lines are out that you realise they’ve denied you goal due to mm
 
Saka is such a wonderful footballer. Far too good for Arsenal.
 
The reality is I don’t think we’re a million miles away from the tech being able to tell a ref very quickly whether someone is offside.
The problem is the fact you think you’ve scored, you watch the first replay and still you’ve scored it’s not until the picture is frozen and the lines are out that you realise they’ve denied you goal due to mm
Which is utter cock as you can’t score with your arm
 
So Wolves being below Man Utd is now a stick to beat the club with? Neves and maybe Neto or Raul are the only players who would get in their best 11
 
So Wolves being below Man Utd is now a stick to beat the club with? Neves and maybe Neto or Raul are the only players who would get in their best 11
They hadn’t beaten us in three years. OGS was by many on here seen as a joke manager. He has done well for that tag . Champions league football beckons.
 
That would be the Champions League he got them knocked out of in the group stages this year by Leipzig who Liverpool took apart
 
Back
Top