Wolves 1-0 Burnley: Verdict Thread

[machin05]

Fucking hell, that would still lead to confusion though wouldn't it? You've narrowed it down to two. Well done.

Not really. Commentator and co-commentator are two very distinct roles.

 

[Sniffer]

OK, let's stop this now please. Thanks.

Discuss the game, that's it

Last chance folks or the thread will be closed.

 

[The Dude]

Or just Google her name?

What an odd hill to die on. It's all a bit pathetic.

You're literally asking for a list of citations for every post on a fucking internet forum. Have a word with yourself.

Posters are allowed to be as detailed or as vague as they choose. You don't make the rules, despite your constant attempts at policing this forum.

 

[The Dude]

Not really. Commentator and co-commentator are two very distinct roles.

If you say so.

 

[The Dude]

Last chance folks or the thread will be closed.

Sorry

 

[Johnny75]

You're literally asking for a list of citations for every post on a fucking internet forum.

Just asking you to not be a stupid misogynist.

And you're telling me you don't know how to use Google?

 

[Del Woppio]

Just to chirp in briefly - closing this thread during this discussion is akin to saying "we don't want misogyny called out and challenged". It's perfectly right that people are calling it out in the (albeit forlorn) hope that the behaviour is modified

 

[The Dude]

Just asking you to not be a stupid misogynist.

And you're telling me you don't know how to use Google?

I've only seen the highlights. I've not commented either way on the quality, or lack thereof of the commentary team.

I'm certainly not a misogynist, I just feel people should be able to express an opinion and call a spade a spade (or a woman a woman), makes things simpler.

 

[Elephant Pyjamas]

The more I watch this, the more I think they were both fairly routine saves?

The first one he spreads himself well, it is straight at him though.

The second one is a save I'd expect any keeper at this level to make? It would have looked awful if that sneaked in the corner.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

To be fair though, after the Ipswich performance they're not saves I'd have thought he was capable of though.

 

[Sniffer]

Just to chirp in briefly - closing this thread during this discussion is akin to saying "we don't want misogyny called out and challenged". It's perfectly right that people are calling it out in the (albeit forlorn) hope that the behaviour is modified

Call it out by all means but start a new thread please.

 

[Del Woppio]

The more I watch this, the more I think they were both fairly routine saves?

The first one he spreads himself well, it is straight at him though.

The second one is a save I'd expect any keeper at this level to make? It would have looked awful if that sneaked in the corner.


To be fair though, after the Ipswich performance they're not saves I'd have thought he was capable of though.

Neither are worldies but both very good, particularly the second one given the time between shots; it's not just the save, it's the awareness and ability to get up, reposition, and set well to face the second shot. Agree though I think most keepers at this level would've done the same, but given most of us thought he was Championship level, doing something as important as that at Premier Leagie level is an achievement

 

[Tony Towner]

The more I watch this, the more I think they were both fairly routine saves?

The first one he spreads himself well, it is straight at him though.

The second one is a save I'd expect any keeper at this level to make? It would have looked awful if that sneaked in the corner.

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

To be fair though, after the Ipswich performance they're not saves I'd have thought he was capable of though.

I thought that when I first saw it, but that was looking coldly post game. A lot of things look better when you are watching them emotionally invested. Sa made a similar save to the first injured on Saturday

 

[machin05]

If you say so.

I'll give you £25 if you can find 3 people that would say otherwise.

 

[Kenny]

Thread won't be closed but those that cannot walk away from the discussion will get 24 hours where they simply cannot post about it or anything else

See new guidelines for more info.

Ta.

 

[The Dude]

I'll give you £25 if you can find 3 people that would say otherwise.

If I had no previous knowledge of football broadcasting and I started watching or listening part way through a game I couldn't differentiate between them.

Even Amazon introduced Guy Mowbray and Courtney double barrel as "commentators".

 

[MARKakaJIM]

Just to chirp in briefly - closing this thread during this discussion is akin to saying "we don't want misogyny called out and challenged". It's perfectly right that people are calling it out in the (albeit forlorn) hope that the behaviour is modified

It got called out 2 days ago, at this point it's just two parties shouting across the street at one another.

 

[Jinky]

Try thinking about why so few females do. Just a thought

Not quite sure why you quoted my post.

 

[Wolf Hunting]

I'll give you £25 if you can find 3 people that would say otherwise.

"otherwise"
That's 1!

 

[Paddingtonwolf]

Not quite sure why you quoted my post.

Nor am I. Something has double quoted which wasn’t my intention. Apologies

 

[Dire Wolf]

Neither are worldies but both very good, particularly the second one given the time between shots; it's not just the save, it's the awareness and ability to get up, reposition, and set well to face the second shot. Agree though I think most keepers at this level would've done the same, but given most of us thought he was Championship level, doing something as important as that at Premier Leagie level is an achievement

The time between the 2 shots and the deflection on the 2nd one make it a very good save. Not outstanding, but still very good.